Understanding backup withholding is essential for businesses that make reportable payments to contractors, vendors, or service providers. This IRS requirement protects federal tax revenue by ensuring tax collection on certain payment types, even when standard withholding doesn’t apply.
This guide breaks down IRS backup withholding rules, explains when it applies, and shows you how to stay compliant.
What Is Backup Withholding?
Backup withholding is a type of federal tax withholding that payers must deduct from certain payments to payees. It serves as a backup method to collect income tax when normal information reporting requirements aren’t satisfied.
The IRS requires backup withholding when:
- A payee fails to provide their correct Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN)
- The IRS notifies the payer that the TIN provided is incorrect
- A payee underreports interest or dividend income on their tax return
- A payee doesn’t certify they aren’t subject to backup withholding when required
Unlike regular withholding tax that applies to wages, backup withholding applies to payments typically made to independent contractors and other non-employees. The withheld amount is credited against the payee’s annual tax liability when they file their return.
When Does Backup Withholding Apply?
Backup withholding applies in four specific circumstances mandated by the IRS.
Missing TIN: When a payee doesn’t provide a TIN on Form W-9 or the applicable form, you must begin backup withholding immediately.
Incorrect TIN: The IRS sends B-Notices (CP2100 or CP2100A) to payers when reported TINs don’t match Social Security Administration or IRS records. After receiving a second notice for the same payee, backup withholding becomes mandatory.
Underreporting of Interest or Dividends: If the IRS notifies you that a payee has underreported taxable interest or dividends, you must withhold on those payment types for at least four years.
Certification Failure: When a payee fails to certify on Form W-9 that they aren’t subject to backup withholding, you must begin withholding until proper certification is received.
What triggers backup withholding varies by situation, but incorrect TIN backup withholding is the most common scenario businesses encounter.
What Is the Backup Withholding Rate?
The backup withholding rate is 24% of the gross payment amount.
This rate has been in effect since 2018, when the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act changed it from the previous 28% rate. The backup withholding rate IRS applies remains consistent across all payment types subject to this withholding.
For example, if you pay a contractor $1,000 and backup withholding applies, you must withhold $240 and remit it to the IRS. The contractor receives $760 and can claim the $240 withholding credit on their tax return.
Who Is Responsible for Backup Withholding?
The payer—not the payee—is responsible for backup withholding compliance.
Businesses and individuals making reportable payments must:
- Collect Form W-9 from all payees before making payments
- Verify TIN information and respond to IRS B-Notices within required timeframes
- Calculate and withhold 24% from applicable payments when conditions are met
- Deposit withheld amounts to the IRS following the deposit schedule for Form 945 filers
- Report backup withholding on Form 945 (Annual Return of Withheld Federal Income Tax)
- Provide payees with Form 1099 showing both gross payments and amounts withheld in Box 4
Failing to properly withhold when required can result in penalties equal to the amount that should have been withheld, plus interest. This makes incorrect TIN penalties particularly costly for businesses.
What Payments Are Subject to Backup Withholding?
Federal backup withholding can apply to most payment types that require information reporting to the IRS.
Common Payment Types
Interest payments: Banks and financial institutions must withhold on interest payments exceeding $10 when conditions are met.
Dividend payments: Both ordinary and qualified dividends are subject to the backup withholding tax when applicable.
Broker and barter exchange transactions: Gross proceeds from sales of securities, commodities, and barter exchange transactions fall under these rules.
Rents, profits, and other income: Payments reported on Form 1099-MISC or Form 1099-NEC, including payments to independent contractors, are subject to backup withholding when required.
Royalty payments: Intellectual property royalties and mineral rights royalties must include backup withholding when conditions apply.
Certain fishing boat proceeds: Reportable payments to crew members may require withholding under specific circumstances.
The connection between backup withholding 1099 forms is direct—if a payment type requires 1099 reporting, it’s generally subject to backup withholding rules.
Backup Withholding vs Regular Withholding
Backup withholding and regular withholding tax serve different purposes in the federal tax system.
Regular withholding applies to employee wages based on Form W-4 elections. The amount varies by individual circumstances, including filing status, dependents, and additional withholding requests. It’s ongoing for all wage payments.
Backup withholding applies to specific payment types made to non-employees and occurs only when IRS requirements aren’t met. The rate is fixed at 24% regardless of the payee’s tax situation. It continues until the underlying issue is resolved.
Backup withholding explained simply: it’s a fallback mechanism when normal reporting breaks down, while regular withholding is the standard tax collection method for employment relationships.
How to Stop or Avoid Backup Withholding
Who is subject to backup withholding can take specific actions to resolve their status.
For payees:
- Provide your correct TIN immediately using Form W-9
- Ensure your name matches Social Security Administration or IRS records exactly
- Respond promptly to any IRS notices about TIN discrepancies
- File all required tax returns and report all income accurately
- Certify you aren’t subject to backup withholding when completing Form W-9
For payers:
- Collect Form W-9 before making any reportable payments
- Use the IRS TIN Matching Program to verify TINs before filing information returns
- Respond to all B-Notices within 15 business days
- Implement systems to track which payees are subject to backup withholding
- Maintain documentation showing when backup withholding began and ended
How to stop backup withholding typically requires correcting the underlying issue. Once resolved, the IRS will notify the payer or the payee can provide updated documentation showing the issue no longer exists.
Using tax software like 1099Pro Cloud helps businesses manage backup withholding rules automatically through built-in validation and tracking features.
Conclusion
Understanding IRS backup withholding protects your business from costly penalties while ensuring compliance with federal tax laws.
The 24% backup withholding rate applies whenever payees don’t meet IRS identification or reporting requirements. As the payer, you’re responsible for proper withholding, timely deposits, and accurate reporting using Form 945 and the appropriate 1099 forms.
Preventing backup withholding issues starts with collecting accurate Form W-9 information, verifying TINs before filing, and maintaining organized records of all reportable payments.
1099Pro Cloud streamlines the entire process—from TIN validation to automatic backup withholding calculations and electronic filing. Start your free trial today and simplify your 1099 reporting compliance.
Frequently Asked Questions
What triggers backup withholding?
Four situations trigger backup withholding: failing to provide a TIN, providing an incorrect TIN (after IRS notification), underreporting interest or dividend income, or failing to certify exemption from backup withholding when required.
What is the IRS backup withholding rate?
The IRS backup withholding rate is 24% of the gross payment amount. This rate has been in effect since 2018 and applies uniformly to all payment types subject to backup withholding.
Does backup withholding apply to 1099 payments?
Yes, backup withholding applies to payments reported on Form 1099-NEC, 1099-MISC, and other 1099 forms when the payee hasn’t provided proper TIN certification or when other backup withholding conditions are met.
Can backup withholding be refunded?
Yes, backup withholding amounts are treated as federal tax payments. If the withheld amount exceeds your actual tax liability, you’ll receive a refund when you file your tax return. The withheld amounts appear on your 1099 forms in Box 4.
How can businesses avoid backup withholding penalties?
Businesses avoid penalties by collecting Form W-9 before making payments, using the IRS TIN Matching Program, responding promptly to B-Notices, withholding when required, depositing withheld amounts timely, and accurately reporting on Form 945. Implementing automated incorrect TIN penalties prevention through tax software significantly reduces compliance risks.
Additional External Resources: